| Most Goals, Both Teams: 9 |
| (08-Jan-00 Colchester United 5-4 Bristol Rovers) |
| Most Goals, One Team: 5 |
| (07-Mar-00 Wigan Athletic 5-1 Blackpool) |
| (04-Mar-00 Stoke City 5-1 Chesterfield) |
| (22-Jan-00 Oxford United 0-5 Bristol Rovers) |
| (08-Jan-00 Colchester United 5-4 Bristol Rovers) |
| (11-Dec-99 Notts County 5-1 AFC Bournemouth) |
| (16-Nov-99 Millwall 5-0 Reading) |
| (02-Nov-99 Burnley 5-0 Wrexham) |
| (16-Oct-99 Blackpool 0-5 Bury) |
| (15-Oct-99 Cambridge United 5-2 Colchester United) |
| (09-Oct-99 Gillingham 5-1 Wrexham) |
| (02-Oct-99 Wycombe Wanderers 5-3 Reading) |
| (04-Sep-99 Bristol City 5-2 Blackpool) |
| (30-Aug-99 Bury 5-2 Colchester United) |
| Biggest Home Victory: 5 |
| (16-Nov-99 Millwall 5-0 Reading) |
| (02-Nov-99 Burnley 5-0 Wrexham) |
| Biggest Away Victory: 5 |
| (22-Jan-00 Oxford United 0-5 Bristol Rovers) |
| (16-Oct-99 Blackpool 0-5 Bury) |
